|
|
||||||||
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2000;119:314-323
© 2000 Mosby, Inc.
SURGERY FOR CONGENITAL HEART DISEASE |
From the Division of Cardiovascular Surgerya and the Division of Cardiology,b The Montreal Childrens Hospital, McGill University Health Center, Montreal, Quebec,Canada.
Address for reprints: Christo I. Tchervenkov, MD, Director, Cardiovascular Surgery, The Montreal Childrens Hospital, Room C-829, 2300 Tupper St, Montreal, Quebec, Canada H3H 1P3.
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
At Montreal Childrens Hospital we adopted in 1987 an institutional policy of early primary repair for all patients with TOF regardless of age, weight, or pulmonary artery size. Since then, no patient with TOF has received a shunt at our institution. This policy has also been used in patients with double-outlet right ventricle (DORV). It was only natural for us to consider early primary repair for patients with coronary anomalies as well.
In this report we review our results of early primary repair in neonates and infants with TOF or DORV and anomalous coronary arteries crossing an obstructed RVOT, using several surgical techniques to avoid the use of a conduit.
| Patients and methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All patients had an anomalous coronary artery crossing the RVOT. This was defined as a coronary artery whose location interfered with the usual surgical repair of the obstructed RVOT and whose sacrifice would seriously compromise the viability of a significant portion of myocardium.
2 The coronary anomalies encountered are illustrated in Fig 1. They consisted of the following: left anterior descending artery (LAD) from right coronary artery (RCA) (n = 10), RCA from LAD (n = 1), LAD from right coronary sinus (n = 1), large conal branch from RCA (n = 7), and large conal branch from LAD (n = 1). Large conal branches were considered significant when they were of similar caliber to or larger than the LAD and coursed down the entire length of the anterior right ventricular wall toward the interventricular septum. In fact, some of these represented a dual LAD system. Their preservation was believed to be essential for myocardial function.
|
Operative techniques.
No patient received a systemic pulmonary shunt because of the anomalous coronary artery and all lesions were repaired at the initial operation. This was accomplished through a median sternotomy with standard cardiopulmonary bypass support after aortic and bicaval cannulation. The mean bypass time was 144.4 minutes (93-236 minutes). The mean crossclamp time was 76.4 minutes (35-150 minutes). Deep hypothermic circulatory arrest, although used in 7 of 10 patients from 1988 through 1993, was used in only 2 of the last 10 patients since 1994. All patients were cooled to reach an average lowest temperature of 16.8°C ± 1.8°C in patients undergoing circulatory arrest and 21.9°C ± 3.3°C in patients operated on with bypass only. Myocardial protection was provided by a single dose of crystalloid cardioplegic solution.
VSD closure.
In all patients, a right ventriculotomy incision was made. In some patients, the ventriculotomy was displaced to either the left or right to avoid damage to the anomalous coronary artery. Furthermore, the ventriculotomy was frequently made obliquely rather than vertically for the same reason. The VSD was closed with a polytetrafluoroethylene patch*
with either interrupted 5-0 Ethibond pledget-supported sutures or a running 5-0 Prolene polypropylene suture (Ethicon, Inc, Somerville, NJ). This was done after the necessary relief of the RVOT obstruction was accomplished by incising and resecting the hypertrophic muscle bundles usually both in the septal and the parietal extension of the conal septum. In 4 of the 6 patients with DORV, the VSD was restrictive and was first enlarged by resection of a triangular portion of the interventricular septum leftward and anteriorly. Intraventricular rerouting was done with a generous elongated polytetrafluoroethylene patch. This was necessary to avoid subaortic obstruction.
RVOT reconstruction.
The type of surgical reconstruction of the RVOT done in each patient was individualized according to the anatomy in the case. It is not our policy to use monocusp valves in any of our TOF or DORV repairs and none were used in this series. Several surgical techniques were performed to avoid the use of a conduit, which was achieved in 18 of the 20 patients. A number of factors determined the surgical technique used. The two most important were the location and course of the anomalous coronary artery and the size of the pulmonary valve anulus. If the pulmonary valve anulus was normal or near normal size, obviating the need for a transannular patch, the relief of RVOT obstruction was accomplished via a ventriculotomy located to avoid injury to the anomalous coronary artery with or without a pulmonary arteriotomy incision. When the pulmonary valve anulus was hypoplastic, necessitating a transannular patch, the presence of an anomalous coronary artery across the site of intended reconstruction necessitated the use of one of several surgical techniques to avoid a conduit.
MPA translocation.
We first used this technique in 1990, and it was subsequently reported by OBlenes, Freedom, and Coles
11 in 1996, who used it in a 3-year-old patient. Although OBlenes, Freedom, and Coles
11 used the technique described by Lecompte and coworkers
12 to bring the pulmonary arteries in front of the aorta, we have not found it desirable to perform the Lecompte maneuver with severely hypoplastic pulmonary arteries in front of a very large ascending aorta. The technique was used in patients requiring a transannular patch in whom the aberrant coronary artery crossed the severely hypoplastic RVOT at or near the pulmonary valve anulus (Fig 2). After mobilization of the MPA and the right and left pulmonary arteries and division of the ductus arteriosus, the MPA was divided just distal to the anulus. The proximal end was oversewn. The distal end was then translocated onto the right ventriculotomy site anterior to the aberrant coronary artery, reconstituting their normal relationship. Half the circumference of the divided MPA was then sutured to the ventriculotomy incision. The anterior wall of the MPA was then opened longitudinally to allow for the appropriate enlargement. The incision could be extended onto the left pulmonary artery in the presence of left pulmonary artery stenosis. After closure of the VSD, the opened pulmonary artery and ventriculotomy incisions were augmented with an autologous transannular pericardial patch. This technique was used in 4 patients.
|
|
|
Pulmonary homograft conduit.
In 2 patients, a pulmonary homograft conduit was required to achieve an adequate RVOT. In 1 patient, the conduit (15-mm homograft) served as the sole right ventricularpulmonary artery connection. In the second patient, an 11-mm homograft was added as an accessory pathway, after a pulmonary valvotomy, because the native RVOT was judged to be too small to act as the sole right ventricularpulmonary artery pathway. We hope that, with time, the native pathway will enlarge adequately, thus rendering a future conduit change unnecessary. Both patients requiring a conduit had an LAD arising from the RCA.
Patient follow-up.
Follow-up was obtained for all patients through clinic visits and cardiology appointments. Mean follow-up was 5.2 years (1-11.3 years), with the follow-up period ending on May 31, 1999. All patients have therefore been followed up for at least 1 year.
Statistics.
Results are expressed as mean or median ± standard deviation. Data were analyzed with the InStat program (GraphPad Software, Inc, San Diego, Calif), using a paired nonparametric test when appropriate.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Only 2 patients required a conduit. In 1 patient, a 15-mm pulmonary homograft was used for the construction of an RVOT at age 1 year. An anomalous LAD had been identified preoperatively by cardiac catheterization, but at operation no other technique could be used. This patient has been followed up for nearly 5 years and remains free of symptoms, with a right ventricleMPA gradient of 25 mm Hg. In the second patient, an 11-mm pulmonary homograft was added to the native RVOT after resection because the pulmonary valve anulus was believed to be inadequate. This patient has also been free of symptoms in the intermediate postoperative period.
Angiographic follow-up was obtained in 9 of 20 patients. Apart from the previously mentioned reoperations, only 1 other patient demonstrated a significant stenosis of the left pulmonary artery, which was treated by percutaneous stenting 47 months after the operation with a good result. This patient had undergone repair via a displaced ventriculotomy and subcoronary suture lines with a transannular patch. Intraoperative right and left pulmonary artery sizes were 8 and 7 mm, respectively. Angiography had demonstrated a stenosed left pulmonary artery with a 40 mm Hg gradient. This patient is now clinically free of symptoms at 4 years after stent placement and 8 years after surgical repair. The remaining 6 patients had no evidence of significant RVOT gradients or abnormalities on cardiac catheterization. All patients (20/20) were clinically free of symptoms at last contact.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Before this decade there were only 5 surgical series dealing with repair of TOF and anomalous coronaries. Berry and McGoon
7 reported in 1973 the Mayo Clinic experience with 27 patients aged 2 to 29 years, in which there was a 30% mortality rate. Most deaths were a result of injury to the anomalous coronary, which caused a myocardial infarction. Meyer and associates
4 reported in 1975 their experience in Houston with 23 patients, in which there was an 8.7% mortality rate, as a result of injury to the anomalous coronary artery. Hurwitz and colleagues
2 reported in 1980 their experience with 25 children, in which there was an 8% mortality rate. In 1987 Humes and coworkers
3 updated the Mayo Clinic experience with 20 new patients and a 15% mortality rate. Previous palliation was used in 60% of these patients. Finally, Landolt and associates
17 reported no mortality among 9 of 11 patients undergoing repair, with 2 infants undergoing palliation. Of significance is that both patients in whom the anomalous coronary artery was injured, and successfully repaired, survived the operation.
Although these surgical series belong to another era of cardiac surgery, a number of conclusions can be drawn from them. Most of the mortality appears to be a result of either injury to the anomalous coronary artery or significant residual RVOT obstruction. These were operations done in children, teenagers, or even young adults. Although it is not clear from the three oldest series how many patients initially received palliation, it must have been a significant number inasmuch as the age at operation was quite old.
2,4,7 It is also unclear what the true denominator in this patient population really was and what would have happened to patients with extreme hypoplasia of the RVOT in the presence of anomalous coronaries. It is clear that no repairs were undertaken in early life. Putting that aside, it is remarkable how few of these patients required the placement of a conduit between the right ventricle and the pulmonary artery.
The only surgical series in the current era was reported in 1998 by Brizard and associates
5 from the Royal Childrens Hospital in Melbourne. They undertook repair in 36 patients with TOF and anomalous coronaries at a median age of 23 months (2.8170 months) and weight of 9.9 kg (5.241 kg), with no early or late mortality. Previous palliation, however, was used in 20 patients (56%). Of importance is the consistent use of a transatrial-transpulmonary approach with limited transannular patch if necessary, reducing the use of right ventricularpulmonary artery conduits to only 2 patients. Although these results are remarkable, it does not appear that this surgical technique can be used consistently in the neonate or young infant. Despite increasing tendency toward earlier repair, the authors recommend initial palliation in young infants of less than 4 months old unless they have exceptionally favorable anatomic characteristics.
At Montreal Childrens Hospital our neonatal and infant surgery program began in 1987.
18-22 Since that time no patient with TOF or DORV of the TOF type at our institution has received a palliative shunt, with all patients referred for operation undergoing primary repair at a median age of less than 6 months. No patients have been denied repair because of age, weight, pulmonary artery size, or preoperative status. Our current policy is to proceed with repair soon after referral in patients having symptoms or to proceed with elective repair at about 3 to 4 months if the patient is free of symptoms. This aggressive approach has allowed us to get as close as possible to the true denominator in this patient population.
Our standard surgical repair of TOF uses a vertical ventriculotomy and transannular patch if the pulmonary anulus is hypoplastic. The VSD is closed via this exposure and we do not use monocusp valves in any of our repairs. In this consecutive series, we have considered the cases of patients with an anomalous coronary artery crossing an obstructed RVOT, as in TOF or DORV with a subaortic VSD. We report no early or late mortality in a consecutive series of 20 neonates and infants, with only 2 requiring a right ventriclepulmonary artery conduit.
This series highlights our institutional philosophy of early repair, with all patients being referred at younger than 1 year old. Although operations were delayed because of nonmedical reasons in 3 patients, the median age at operation was 5.5 months, which is similar to the median age in our patients with TOF or DORV without anomalous coronary arteries.
23 These results are in accordance with those of other TOF series, in which primary repair in infancy has been associated with an in-hospital mortality rate of 0% to 3%.
24-27
From an operative standpoint, this series illustrates some of the surgical techniques available to allow RVOT reconstruction without a conduit in the presence of an anomalous coronary artery. The techniques used in 18 (90%) of 20 patients in our series included translocation of the MPA,
11 transannular patch under a mobilized LAD,
13 displaced ventriculotomy and subcoronary suture lines, and ventriculotomy with or without pulmonary arteriotomy.
4,5 Whereas most techniques have been previously described, translocation of the MPA onto the right ventricle without the Lecompte maneuver has some potential advantages in the patient with a severely hypoplastic pulmonary valve anulus. These include lower probability of RVOT obstruction or MPA stenosis, because the posterior wall of the constructed pathway consists of autogenous tissue with growth potential, and a lower probability of injury to the underlying anomalous vessel. However, despite full mobilization of the MPA and its confluent branches, this technique may not be possible if the anomalous coronary traverses the lower portion of the RVOT. In such cases, a reverse pulmonary artery flap repair over the anomalous coronary,
15,28 a transannular patch repair under a mobilized LAD, or a displaced ventriculotomy and subcoronary suture lines should be considered. A conduit may be required as a last resort to allow primary repair.
The use of conduits in the infant population carries a risk of recurrent RVOT obstruction, with the need for reoperation as the child outgrows the prosthesis. It will be interesting to see whether the native pathway will grow adequately in the presence of an accessory conduit, as we have used in 1 patient, and consequently prevent future conduit changes.
The mean follow-up of more than 5 years in this study, with no early or late mortality and only two reoperations, suggests that early primary repair is appropriate in this group of patients.
| Conclusion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Appendix: Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Several aspects of the proposed techniques create some concern for me personally. Four patients underwent translocation of the MPA. This operation would seem to place the right pulmonary artery on tension as it courses behind the aorta. Is there any sign of right pulmonary artery obstruction in this small subset of patients during the interim follow-up?
Dr Tchervenkov. Thank you for your kind comments. The reason we kept those 2 patients in the series is simply to have a consecutive series of 20 patients, not excluding anyone.
We share your concern regarding tension on the right pulmonary artery. As a matter of fact, the only patient who had the conduit as the right ventriclepulmonary artery connection was a patient in whom we contemplated doing an MPA translocation technique. The possibility of excessive tension on the branch pulmonary arteries prevented us from using that technique. I think the MPA translocation technique can be used primarily when the anomalous coronary artery crosses either at or slightly below the hypoplastic pulmonary valve anulus. If the anomalous vessel crosses the outflow tract well below, I do not think this technique can be used safely. We have used other techniques in those situations. Of note in the literature is the technique of using a reversed flap of anterior pulmonary arterial wall to bridge over the anomalous coronary artery.
Dr Lamberti. I also am concerned about mobilizing the LAD and placing a patch beneath it. It would seem that aneurysmal dilatation of the patch might stretch the artery during long-term follow-up. Subcoronary suture lines have always made me nervous. I have used the technique on enough occasions to know that it works. Sometimes I had not planned on placing the sutures that close to the coronary artery. In long-term follow-up at 20 years, we have noted dysfunction of the free wall of the right ventricle in some of our patients in whom the outflow tract was sutured very close to a large conal or muscular coronary artery. All of your patients are described as asymptomatic. Do you have any information regarding right ventricular function or exercise testing which might suggest that the blood supply to the right or left ventricle has been compromised by these techniques?
Dr Tchervenkov. Again, those are valid concerns. Immediately on completion of the repair, all coronary arteries, particularly the anomalous ones, were full. The myocardial contractility of the region supplied by the anomalous vessel was excellent, both visually and on echocardiogram, and that has remained so at longer follow-up. We have done postoperative cardiac catheterizations in slightly less than half the patients, and the contractility appears to be well preserved. In using the technique of subcoronary suture lines, it is important to stay away from the anomalous coronary artery, perhaps about 3 to 4 mm away.
Dr Lamberti. All the VSDs were closed through a ventriculotomy. We have often used transatrial repair of VSD in association with limited ventriculotomy in similar patients. Have you considered transatrial patch closure of the VSD? If not, would you consider it useful in this setting?
Dr Tchervenkov. Again, this is a personal preference. In my series of TOF repairs, I have used the transatrial technique only twice in patients with a very well developed RVOT. I was not trained using that technique and therefore I have not adopted it. I am not aware of evidence on long-term follow-up that demonstrates the superiority of the transatrial approach in comparable series of patients. Is there a difference between coring out extensive myocardium from inside to adequately relieve obstruction versus making an incision in the outflow tract and raising the roof of the pathway with a lesser degree of resection on the inside? This question used to be raised by my teacher, Dr Aldo Castaneda.
Dr Lamberti. You limited the paper to primary repair and I understand that concept with regard to the title. However, did you encounter any patients with prior palliation who had the same anatomy? If so, how did you treat them and what were their outcomes?
Dr Tchervenkov. I have been impressed by the relatively longer distances that must be bridged by the various techniques in the older, previously palliated patient, when comparing two cohorts of patientsthe ones from my own institution, who are referred earlier, and the ones referred from outside. In the neonate and infant those distances are extremely small, the tissues are very elastic and pliable, and it is often possible to bridge the same relative distance with greater ease than in an older child.
Dr Vaughn Starnes(Los Angeles, Calif). I have a question regarding the mean right ventricular/left ventricular ratio. You say it is 0.47 at the time of discharge. I believe the right ventricular pressure is relatively high. You call it the mean pressure, so I imagine some of them are higher, and you include pulmonary insufficiency. Have you looked at any of these ventricles by echocardiography or any other follow-up studies to search for right ventricular dysfunction, an enlarging right ventricle, relatively high pressure, and pulmonary insufficiency?
Dr Tchervenkov. The right ventricular/left ventricular pressure ratio may be slightly higher than after regular TOF repair. At 24 to 48 hours after the operation, it is in the range of 0.45. I do not think this is unlike the ratio observed in many other series that have used different surgical techniques. The patients with some right ventricular dilatation have also had some degree of distal obstruction. You must keep in mind that our consistent approach of performing early primary repair on all patients with TOF, regardless of pulmonary artery size, age, or weight of the patient, allows us to detect all of the patients, at least in our referral area. For these reasons, we are obviously seeing a number of patients with severe distal pulmonary artery hypoplasia without necessarily distal anatomic obstruction. The distal pulmonary arterial bed is rather small, and some of these patients have had a very low Nakata index. Right ventricular function is not very easy to assess. There is also significant discrepancy between centers in the rate of pulmonary valve placement at late follow-up. We have not done an elaborate assessment, including exercise testing, in this series of patients.
Dr Starnes. Your bias is not to insert a monocusp of some variety, whether it be tissue or polytetrafluoroethylene. Is that because of concern about reoperation?
Dr Tchervenkov. I think my bias simply reflects the way I was trained by Aldo Castaneda and colleagues in Boston. They did not use a monocusp valve and had excellent results. The long-term follow-up appears to be withstanding the test of time. Our own results not using a monocusp valve are more than acceptable. There are publications comparing the use of monocusp patch versus not using one. There was recently a publication from Toronto that showed no difference in the degree of pulmonary regurgitation in the presence or absence of a monocusp valve. Obviously, we all have personal biases based on our training and personal experience. However, if you find that using the monocusp patch leads to a better outcome or perhaps more comfort for the surgeon, by all means use it. I am a little bit concerned that those monocusp patches may become obstructive with time, necessitating reoperation.
Dr Frank Hanley(Berkeley, Calif). I would like to comment on the issue of using right ventricular/left ventricular pressure ratios in neonates and small infants. There are some concerning misunderstandings with our continued use of this ratio. We have to remember that one of John Kirklins many contributions was linking the right ventricular/left ventricular pressure ratio to long-term outcome. We also have to remember that those children underwent repair at several years of age, when systemic systolic pressures are in the range of 100 to 120 mm Hg. The right ventricular/left ventricular pressure ratio in this setting suggests a certain right ventricular pressure. For unclear reasons, it was decided to use this ratio rather than the absolute right ventricular pressure. Now we are performing TOF repairs in neonates and young infants, in 2.5- and 3-kg children who are still under fentanyl anesthesia and being supported with the ventilator. At the time of the pulmonary artery pressure measurement, the systemic blood pressure may be only 45 or 50 mm Hg. A right ventricular/ left ventricular pressure ratio of 0.6 in this setting sounds high, but in fact the absolute right ventricular pressure may be only 33 mm Hg. It is important to emphasize that the absolute right ventricular pressures are lower than the ratio implies.
Dr Tchervenkov. I fully endorse your comments. We have made exactly the same observation. As a matter of fact, one of the main reasons the right ventricular/left ventricular pressure ratio has fallen by 24 to 48 hours is that whereas the systemic pressure tends to rise, the right ventricular pressure remains the same and results in a more favorable ratio. We should not lose sight of the fact that some of these patients have very small distal pulmonary artery beds. Once these distal beds accept the full cardiac output, it is going to take some time before they fully develop.
| Footnotes |
|---|
*Gore-Tex polytetrafluoroethylene patch. Gore-Tex is a registered trademark of W. L. Gore &Associates, Inc, Flagstaff, Ariz.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
W.-J. Luo, R.-M. Huang, Y. Tang, and B. Li Right Coronary Artery Translocation in Tetralogy of Fallot Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann, February 1, 2008; 16(1): 73 - 75. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. S. Gulati, C. Singh, S. S. Kothari, and S. Sharma An Unusual Coronary Artery Anomaly in Tetralogy of Fallot Shown on MDCT. Am. J. Roentgenol., April 1, 2006; 186(4): 1192 - 1193. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Hekmat, S. Rafieyian, M. Foroughi, M. M Majidi Tehrani, M. Beheshti Monfared, and S. A Hassantash Associated Coronary Anomalies in 135 Iranian Patients with Tetralogy of Fallot Asian Cardiovasc Thorac Ann, December 1, 2005; 13(4): 307 - 310. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Pretre, G. Gendron, D. Tamisier, F. Vernant, D. Sidi, and P. Vouhe Results of the Lecompte procedure in malposition of the great arteries and pulmonary obstruction Eur. J. Cardiothorac. Surg., March 1, 2001; 19(3): 283 - 289. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Aeba, T. Katogi, I. Kashima, K. Moro, T. Ito, S. Kawada, and E. Takahashi Left atrial appendage insertion for right ventricular outflow tract reconstruction Ann. Thorac. Surg., February 1, 2001; 71(2): 501 - 505. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |