|
|
||||||||
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2001;121:723-728
© 2001 The American Association for Thoracic Surgery
Surgery for Acquired Cardiovascular Disease |
From the Department of Cardio-Thoracic and Respiratory Sciences, V. Monaldi Hospital, Second University of Naples, Italy.
Received for publication July 18, 2000. Revisions requested Aug 22, 2000; revisions received Nov 10, 2000. Accepted for publication Nov 14, 2000. Address for reprints: Attilio Renzulli, MD, FECTS, Via Aquila 144, 80143, Napoli, Italy (E-mail: arenzul{at}tin.it renzulliattilio@usanet).
Abstract
Objective: We reviewed our experience with aortic valve replacement using 19-mm St Jude Medical prostheses (St Jude Medical, Inc, St Paul, Minn) in 119 patients, among which 68 (group A) had a Standard model and 51 (group B) had a Hemodynamic Plus model.
Methods: Comparison between the 2 models included analysis of early and late mortality and all valve-related complications. Postoperative echocardiography was performed to evaluate the hemodynamic performance of both prosthetic models. Laboratory tests were performed to evaluate the amount of red blood cell damage caused by the transprosthetic turbulent flow.
Results: Average body surface area was 1.66 ± 0.14 m2 in group A and 1.65 ± 0.16 m2 in group B (P = .72). There was no statistically significant difference between the 2 groups in terms of preoperative variables (sex, cardiac rhythm, body surface area, preoperative gradients, and New York Heart Association class). Five-year follow-up was 100% complete. Although group A patients had significantly higher postoperative peak and mean gradients (P = .0001) and a lower effective orifice area (P = .0001), no statistical differences were found in terms of late (5-year) survival (P = .6) and postoperative complications (P = .09). Moreover, postoperative left ventricular mass was found to be similar in the 2 groups (P = .18). Hematologic evaluation did not show any significant difference between the 2 groups as to incidence of hemolysis.
Conclusions: Aortic valve replacement with 19-mm aortic prostheses in patients with a body surface area of less than 1.7 m2 allows good results. Although Hemodynamic Plus models have better hemodynamic results, no significant difference was found in terms of clinical results and clinical hemolysis.
The replacement of the aortic valve with any kind of device implies the acceptance of a residual gradient.
1-3 The use of an aortic valve prosthesis in the small anulus raises concerns about the harmful effects of residual obstruction to left ventricular outflow.
4-7 Residual gradient is the driving stimulus for incomplete regression of left ventricular hypertrophy after aortic valve replacement (AVR), and it has been related to higher long-term incidence of cardiac complications and mortality.
8-11 An indexed orifice area of less than 0.9 cm2/m2 has been associated with a higher incidence of late complications, including sudden death.
3,12
Tilting disc and stented porcine 19-mm valves have both shown poor hemodynamic performance in the aortic position.
1,6,11,13 On the other hand, bileaflet valves are still the most implanted cardiac valve substitutes in the aortic position. Their excellent durability and low incidence of cardiac-related complications have been widely reported in the medical literature.
1,5,14,15
Although valve manufacturers have recently improved hemodynamic performances of small aortic prostheses, the implantation of small-valve prostheses in the aortic position is still considered to imply the risk of high residual gradients.
5,6,15,16
The purpose of this retrospective study is to evaluate and compare the clinical and hemodynamic performance of 19-mm St Jude Medical Hemodynamic Plus (HP) and Standard valves (St Jude Medical, Inc, St Paul, Minn) implanted in the aortic position.
Materials and methods
Between January 1983 and December 1997, 119 isolated 19-mm St Jude Medical bileaflet aortic prostheses were implanted at our institution. Patients were distributed into 2 groups according to the prosthesis model: group A included 68 patients with the Standard model, and group B included 51 patients with the HP model. Preoperative clinical and echocardiographic data are reported in Tables I and II, respectively.
|
|
Surgical procedure
After median sternotomy, all patients underwent AVR with a 19-mm mechanical bileaflet prosthesis under mild hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass. Myocardial protection was achieved both with topical hypothermia and with intermittent infusion of cold crystalloid solution (St Thomas' Hospital) directly into the coronary ostia. The procedure was always performed by the same group of surgeons.
12 Aortic prostheses were implanted in the intra-annular position with nonpledget-supported simple interrupted sutures (Tevdek 2-0; Deknatel, Inc, Fall River, Mass). The hinge area was positioned at 90° with the interventricular septum. By policy, in our experience an associate patch enlargement of the aortic anulus was considered only in patients with an expected indexed effective orifice area (IEOA) of less than 0.9 cm2/m2.
Anticoagulation protocol
All patients were treated with oral anticoagulation, which was carried out in all cases with warfarin sodium. Ninety percent of our patients were followed up in our anticoagulation clinic. The others were referred to a satellite institution following the same anticoagulation protocol as our center. Prothrombin activity was kept between 25% and 35%, which equals an international normalized ratio ranging between 2.0 and 3.5.
Clinical evaluation and definition of complications
Patients operated on in our institution are commonly seen at least yearly in our outpatient clinic where they undergo clinical examination (including blood pressure measurement) and, when indicated, echocardiographic study. Hospital records were checked retrospectively to achieve hospital mortality and morbidity data. No patient was lost to follow-up. Cumulative mortality and morbidity was labeled as "treatment failure" (including hospital mortality, late mortality, and all valve-related complications).
17,18
Echocardiographic study
All surviving patients underwent M-B mode color Doppler echocardiographic evaluation preoperatively and during the follow-up period. Postoperative echocardiography was performed every 6 months.
The modified Bernoulli equation was used to calculate the instantaneous pressure gradients across the prosthesis. The velocity in the left ventricular outflow tract (LVOT) was considered in gradient calculation by including it in the equation. The mean pressure gradient was calculated by averaging the gradient at 40-ms intervals throughout the velocity complexes. Peak velocity measurements were performed with a pulsed wave Doppler echocardiographic scanner by using the lower angle as soon as possible. The peak velocity was obtained by averaging from 3 measured velocities. Velocities across the prosthesis were recorded a few minutes after the end of the exercise because at this time the peak flow velocity reaches its highest level. The effective orifice area (EOA) of the prosthesis was calculated with the following continuity equation by mean of the simplified peak velocity method:
EOA = CSA (PkVLVOT/PkVjet)
where CSA is the cross-sectional area of the LVOT, and PkVLVOT and PkVjet are the maximal velocity in the LVOT and across the valve, respectively. This simplified method has shown a good correlation with that of the original continuity equation. Furthermore, the cross-sectional area of the LVOT was determined by assuming that the sewing ring size was the cross-sectional diameter of the LVOT.
In all cases the IEOA (IEOA = EOA/BSA [body surface area]) and indexed left ventricular mass (LVM) were calculated. BSA was calculated according to the formula of Dubois.
Hematologic evaluation of hemolysis
All patients were informed about the purpose of the study, and all of them gave written consent. A 20-mL blood sample was taken every week for 2 weeks to perform the following measurements: (1) blood hemoglobin (in grams per deciliter); (2) serum lactic dehydrogenase (in units per liter); (3) percent-correlated reticulocyte fraction; (4) serum haptoglobin (in grams per liter); and (5) schistocytes (percent). The data were recorded, and the final results were expressed as the mean value of the 2 blood tests.
The criteria proposed by Skoularigis and colleagues
19 were used to define hemolysis. Patients were considered as having intravascular hemolysis when serum lactic dehydrogenase (LDH) levels were elevated (>460 U/L, major criteria) and at least 2 of the following minor criteria were observed:
Statistical analysis
Statistical analysis was performed with the SPSS statistical software package (SPSS, Inc, Chicago, Ill). Categoric values of the 2 groups were compared by using the
2 or Fisher exact tests, whereas continuous data, reported as means ± SD, were compared by using the Student t test. Time-related analysis of late complications was calculated as the percentage of events per year. Univariate survival and actuarial analysis were performed with the Kaplan-Meier method and were compared with the log-rank test.
Results
Clinical results
Hospital mortality
A total of 8 (6.7%) patients died during their hospital stay; 7 (10.3%) belonged to group A, and 1 (2%) belonged to group B (P = .153). Causes of death were low output syndrome in 6 patients (5 patients of group A and 1 patient of group B; P = .08), mediastinitis in 1 patient, and disseminate intravascular coagulopathy in 1 patient.
Late mortality
Four patients died during the follow-up; 3 (4.9%) of them had a Standard model prosthesis (group A), and 1 (2%) had an HP model prosthesis (group B) (P = .757). Causes of late death were sudden death in 2 patients, both belonging to group A (transprosthetic mean gradients at the last echocardiographic control were 25 and 35 mm Hg, respectively); cancer in 1 patient; and road accident in 1 patient. Five-year actuarial survival did not show any significant difference between the 2 groups (group A, 93.4% ± 4%; group B, 96.15% ± 37%, P = .6; 13-year actuarial survival in group A was 90.89% ± 6%).
Clinical status
Mean New York Heart Association class at latest follow-up was 1.2 ± 0.7 in group A versus 1.1 ± 0.6 in group B (P = .14). There was no statistical difference between the 2 groups in terms of peripheral blood pressure (group A: mean systolic pressure of 145 ± 15 mm Hg and mean diastolic pressure of 80 ± 10 mm Hg; group B: mean systolic pressure of 140 ± 20 mm Hg and mean diastolic pressure of 75 ± 10 mm Hg) at follow-up. Moreover, there was no statistical difference between the 2 groups in terms of requirement of cardiovascular drugs (group A, 40/61 [65.6%] patients; group B, 32/50 [64%] patients).
Embolism
There was no statistical difference between rates of freedom from embolism in the 2 groups at 5 years of follow-up. No case of embolism was observed in any group of patients (100% event free) within the first 5 years of follow-up. Two patients of group A had a neurologic complication caused by embolism after the fifth postoperative year, resulting in a 13-year event-free rate of 89.41% ± 7%.
Hemorrhage
No case of hemorrhage was observed in patients with HP prostheses (100% event free). One patient with the Standard 19-mm prosthesis had gastric bleeding that required blood transfusion (13-year freedom from hemorrhage in group A, 98.25% ± 2%). No statistical difference was found between the 2 groups at 5 years of follow-up.
Endocarditis, thrombosis, and reoperation
No cases of endocarditis, prosthetic thrombosis, and reoperation have been reported during the follow-up.
Treatment failure
Cumulative analysis of events, including early and late mortality and all valve-related complications, did not show any statistically significant difference at 5 years of follow-up (group A, 89.25% ± 7%; group B, 93.24% ± 5%; P = .09). Thirteen-year freedom from treatment failure in group A was 73.27% ± 9% (Fig 1).
|
Hematologic results
No pathologic levels of serum haptoglobin, reticulocytes, and schistocytes were observed in both groups. Haptoglobin levels and percent-corrected reticulocyte fractions were statistically lower in patients with the Standard prosthesis (Table III). The mean count of schistocytes was statistically lower (Pd = .005) in patients with the HP prosthesis(Table III
).
|
Low levels of blood hemoglobin (13.7 ± 1.6 g/dL in group B patients and 13.4 ± 1.4 g/dL in group A patients) were found (P = not significant).
According to the criteria
19 previously reported, 14 (24.14%) of 58 group A patients and 13 (26.5%) of 49 group B patients showed some degree of intravascular hemolysis (P = not significant,Table III
).
Discussion
The objective of AVR is to restore valvular function with the lowest transprosthetic gradient. To improve hemodynamic performances of aortic valve prostheses, new models of bileaflet valves have been devised, reducing the suture cuff.
6,15 At the same time, stentless porcine valves have been commercialized to minimize transprosthetic gradients.
9,10,20 In patients with stentless valves, minimal transprosthetic gradients and almost complete LVM regression have been reported.
9,20
In the early decades of cardiac operations, hemodynamic evaluation of mechanical aortic prostheses was almost impossible.
21-23 Surgeons used to evaluate transprosthetic gradients intraoperatively.
Doppler ultrasonographymeasured pressure gradients across different types of bioprosthetic and mechanical valves are reported to correlate well with catheter-derived gradients.
24-26 Although bileaflet valves have a central flow and should allow an accurate measurement of gradients, the presence of pressure recovery and high localized pressure gradients might cause some overestimation compared with the catheter pressure gradient, as found by Baumgartner and associates
26 in St Jude Medical valves. The results of a proper match between patients and prostheses can be evaluated by means of echocardiography through ventricular mass regression.
2,9,12,13
Nowadays, assessment of bileaflet valve performances must include clinical and echocardiographic studies. In addition, high gradients and flow turbulence have been associated with significant hemolysis.
19,27,28
Many studies, in which the performances of different aortic valve prostheses were evaluated, have emphasized that successful AVR should achieve an indexed valve area greater than 0.9 cm2/m2 to minimize prosthetic gradients and obtain postoperative LVM regression.
3,8,11,12
Therefore, there are some controversies about the long-term effect of residual transprosthetic gradient in patients with a small aortic anulus and an expected IEOA greater than 0.9 cm2/m2. Furthermore, the advantages and the intermediate-term results of new and improved orifice models are still to be fully assessed.
Transprosthetic gradients are correlated to cardiac output and BSA. The BSA of Mediterranean patients older than 60 years referred for AVR averages 1.66 m2. In our study, a critical value of IEOA of less than 0.9 was not observed in any patient.
This study confirms that as long as the EOA of bileaflet aortic valve implanted in adult patients with normal body size is greater than 0.9 to 1 cm2/m2, hemodynamic performances are good, and long-term clinical results are excellent. Hachida and colleagues,
29 although studying a group of patients with smaller BSAs than ours and with pure aortic stenosis alone, reported postoperative results that are consistent with our findings as far as peak and mean gradients and postoperative indexed LVM are concerned, particularly in patients with HP models. However, we could not explain the discrepancy between that study and ours in the postoperative EAO of both Standard and HP valves. In no study have HP valves, despite their better hemodynamic results, been shown to significantly improve clinical results. However, a 91% survival at 13 years in patients with Standard model prostheses and a mean age of 65 years is already a good result when compared with other recent series.
30,31
This study analyses our 16-year experience with 19-mm Standard and HP St Jude Medical aortic prostheses retrospectively. A retrospective analysis of such a wide time period may imply limitations related to changes in diagnostic, operative, or both types of technologies and techniques. Length of follow-up is different between the 2 groups because HP models have been available in our institution since 1994. However, the longer follow-up belongs to the model that has worse hemodynamic performances. Moreover, time-related analysis of events was truncated at 5 years for both groups to achieve comparable data. Although in our study no significant difference between the 2 groups of patients was found in terms of late survival, it must be pointed out that most of the patients from group B have not yet reached 4 years of follow-up. No LVM regression analysis was performed because such data have been available in our institution only in recent years. Another limitation to our study can be represented by the mean age of patients because a lower physical activity is expected in patients older than 60 years.
It must be pointed that because bileaflet valves in the aortic position usually carry low degrees of hemolysis,
19 differences between similar models can be difficult to ascertain with the common hematologic tests.
28 The criteria of Skoularigis and colleagues
19 have been proven to be effective in evaluating the amount of intravascular hemolysis and to perform comparisons between different models of mechanical valves. Nevertheless, according to such criteria, no significant difference between the HP and Standard series was found as to late postoperative intravascular hemolysis, although mean LDH serum levels and schistocyte count were significantly lower in group B. It can be stated that subclinical blood cell damage could be significantly higher in patients with standard 19-mm aortic prostheses compared with those receiving HP prostheses.
In conclusion, our study confirms that 19-mm bileaflet aortic valves allow good long-term clinical results and acceptable hemodynamic results in patients with a BSA of less than 1.7 m2. Improved orifice models allow lower gradients, but such data do not affect clinical results and the amount of red blood cell damage.
References
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
S. Kohsaka, S. Mohan, S. Virani, V.-V. Lee, A. Contreras, G. J. Reul, and S. A. Coulter Prosthesis-patient mismatch affects long-term survival after mechanical valve replacement. J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., May 1, 2008; 135(5): 1076 - 1080. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
D. Mohty-Echahidi, J. F. Malouf, S. E. Girard, H. V. Schaff, D. E. Grill, M. E. Enriquez-Sarano, and F. A. Miller Jr Impact of Prosthesis-Patient Mismatch on Long-Term Survival in Patients With Small St Jude Medical Mechanical Prostheses in the Aortic Position Circulation, January 24, 2006; 113(3): 420 - 426. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
R. Vink, R. A. Kraaijenhagen, B. A. Hutten, R. B. A. van den Brink, B. A. de Mol, H. R. Buller, and M. Levi The optimal intensity of vitamin k antagonists in patients with mechanical heart valves: A meta-analysis J. Am. Coll. Cardiol., December 17, 2003; 42(12): 2042 - 2048. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Niinami, S. Aomi, H. Tomioka, K. Nakano, and H. Koyanagi A comparison of the in vivo performance of the 19-mm St. Jude medical hemodynamic plus and 21-mm standard valve Ann. Thorac. Surg., October 1, 2002; 74(4): 1120 - 1124. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. D. Milano, M. De Carlo, G. Mecozzi, A. D'Alfonso, G. Scioti, C. Nardi, and U. Bortolotti Clinical outcome in patients with 19-mm and 21-mm St. Jude aortic prostheses: comparison at long-term follow-up Ann. Thorac. Surg., January 1, 2002; 73(1): 37 - 43. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |