| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
|
|
|
|||||||
|
|||||||||
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2002;123:119-129
© 2002 The American Association for Thoracic Surgery
Surgery for Congential Heart Disease |
From The Division of Cardiovascular Surgery, The Heart Institute for Children, Hope Children's Hospital, Oak Lawn, Ill, and The Division of Cardiothoracic Surgery, The University of Illinois of Chicago, Chicago, Ill.
*Supported in part by the Pillsbury Fellowship.
Received for publication Sept 13, 2000. Revisions requested Feb 2, 2001; revisions received June 6, 2001. Accepted for publication July 27, 2001. Address for reprints: Bradley S. Allen, MD, The Heart Institute for Children, Hope Children's Hospital, 4440 W 95th St, Oak Lawn, IL 60453.
Abstract
Objectives: This study was undertaken to compare conventional cardioplegic strategies with a new approach that uses a modified nonpotassium maintenance solution between cardioplegia doses in stressed neonatal hearts.
Methods: Thirty-five neonatal piglets underwent 60 minutes of ventilator hypoxia (inspired oxygen fraction 8%-10%) followed by 20 minutes of ischemia on cardiopulmonary bypass. In 10 animals bypass was discontinued without further ischemia (stress control group). The other 25 received a warm blood cardioplegic induction and were separated into 5 groups. In 5 animals cardiopulmonary bypass was discontinued without further ischemia (cardioplegia control group); the remaining 20 underwent an additional 70 minutes of cold blood cardioplegic arrest. Five received only intermittent cardioplegia every 20 minutes, whereas 15 also received cold blood maintenance infusions between cardioplegic doses (integrated strategy). In 5 of these animals the blood was unmodified, whereas in 10 a modified nonpotassium "cardioplegia-like" solution was delivered either antegradely (n = 5) or retrogradely (n = 5). Myocardial function was assessed by pressure-volume loops (expressed as percentage of control); vascular function was assessed by coronary vascular resistance.
Results: All piglets that underwent hypoxic ischemic stress alone (controls) died. Warm induction alone (cardioplegic controls) partially repaired the stress injury. Intermittent cardioplegia preserved the depressed systolic function (end-systolic elastance 40% vs 39%), increased diastolic stiffness (255% vs 239%), reduced adenosine triphosphate (10.6 vs 12.2 µg/g tissue), and elevated coronary vascular resistance at levels identical to warm induction alone; infusing unmodified blood between cardioplegia doses (standard integrated) improved results slightly. In contrast, infusion of a cold modified solution (antegrade or retrograde) between cardioplegia doses (modified integrated) completely restored systolic function (end-systolic elastance 100% and 97%, P < .001 vs intermittent and standard integrated), only minimally increased diastolic stiffness (159% and 156%, P < .001 vs intermittent and standard integrated), restored adenosine triphosphate (18.8 and 16.6 µg/g, P < .001 vs intermittent and standard integrated), and normalized coronary vascular resistance (P < .001 vs intermittent and standard integrated). This strategy was used in 72 consecutive hypoxic patients (21 arterial switch operations, retrograde; 51 Fontan procedures, antegrade) with a 2.8% mortality.
Conclusions: Infusion of a cold modified solution between cardioplegic doses (modified integrated protection) significantly improved myocardial protection in the stressed neonatal heart, was effective delivered either antegradely or retrogradely, and was used successfully for hypoxic (stressed) pediatric patients.
After cardioplegic arrest, most surgeons deliver intermittent cardioplegia every 15 to 20 minutes to maintain myocardial arrest, restore hypothermia, buffer acidosis, and wash away acid metabolites.
1,2 This is traditional, but a dry field is not always required between cardioplegic doses. To further limit ischemia and improve protection, we introduced the concept of integrated cardioplegia, which consists of infusing a maintenance solution of unmodified cold (4°C) blood between intermittent cardioplegic doses whenever visualization is not impaired by coronary perfusion. 1,3,4 Cold unmodified blood is used for the maintenance infusions; because hypothermia alone tends to keep the heart arrested, it allows the infusions to be safely interrupted when a dry field is required for optimal visualization, and it avoids administration of large quantities of potassium. Despite excellent clinical results in adult patients, the standard integrated strategy has never been evaluated experimentally and is rarely used in pediatric patients. 1,3,4 Indeed, several studies in pediatric hearts have suggested that multiple intermittent cardioplegic infusions are no better, and may even be worse, than a single cold infusion. 2,5,6
Postoperative myocardial dysfunction, however, remains the primary cause of morbidity and mortality in pediatric patients, occurring most frequently in the presence of cyanosis. 2,6-9 Hypoxia is associated with metabolic adaptations that allow normal aerobic metabolism to persist in the resting state. However, this compensatory mechanism is expended readily with stress, as atrial pacing or catecholamine infusion causes myocardial lactate production, indicating ischemia with a shift toward anaerobic metabolism. 10,11 This metabolic shift may occur in cyanotic patients during the stresses of daily life, such as exercise, emotional upset, and tachycardia, and may become compounded during anoxic spells. Hypoxic hearts are also more vulnerable to accelerated depletion of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) during surgical ischemia, as well as predisposed toward reoxygenation injury with the reintroduction of oxygen. 5,8,12 Consequently, the cyanotic pediatric heart is more vulnerable than the normoxic adult heart to inadequacies in myocardial protection and might derive an even greater benefit from an integrated approach that limits ischemia.
To parallel this experimentally, we used stressed (hypoxic and ischemic) neonatal hearts to evaluate the conventional techniques of intermittent cardioplegia and standard integrated protection. The standard integrated strategy has the potential problem of producing a reperfusion injury, however, because it exposes the ischemic heart to multiple infusions of cold unmodified blood, which Rebeyka and associates 13 have shown is dangerous in infants. We therefore also evaluated a new approach, which replaces the cold unmodified blood with a cold modified (nonpotassium, magnesium-enriched, citrate-phosphate-dextrose, tromethamine) blood solution. We termed this the "modified integrated strategy." Use of a modified nonpotassium "cardioplegia-like" blood solution for the maintenance infusions has the potential advantage of reducing any reperfusion injury, because cardioplegia limits reperfusion damage after ischemia, and the heart is ischemic between cardioplegic doses. 1,14,15 Hyperkalemia is avoided by not adding potassium, and the heart is kept arrested by hypothermia as well as by changes in magnesium and calcium. To more closely mimic clinical experience, we also determined whether the method of delivery (antegrade vs retrograde) affected results. This simulates operations such as the arterial switch procedure, where antegrade perfusion is not possible after the initial cardioplegia dose. On the basis of the experimental infrastructure provided by these studies, we incorporated a modified integrated strategy into our clinical practice and examined the results in 72 high-risk patients (Fontan and arterial switch procedures).
Methods
Thirty-five neonatal (5- to 18-day-old) piglets (3.5 to 5 kg) were intramuscularly medicated with 40 mg/kg ketamine, were intraperitoneally anesthetized with 30 mg/kg phenobarbital followed by 5 mg/kg intravenously each hour, and had the lungs ventilated through a tracheotomy with a volume ventilator (Servo 900B; Siemens/ Elema, Solna, Sweden). All animals received humane care in compliance with the "Principles of Laboratory Animal Care" formulated by the National Society for Medical Research, and "Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals," prepared by the National Academy of Sciences and published by the National Institutes of Health (NIH), Publication No. 96-03, Revised 1996. The experimental preparation, including cannulation for bypass, the bypass prime, and blood sample procurement, was comparable with that previously described elsewhere. 5,12,16
Experimental protocols
Hypoxic-ischemic stress
All 35 piglets underwent 60 minutes of ventilator hypoxia by lowering the fraction of inspired oxygen to 8% to 10% to produce an arterial PO2 of 25 to 35 mm Hg and an oxygen saturation of 65% to 70%. Before hypoxemia, piglets were transfused as necessary to increase the hematocrit to greater than 35%. This simulated the chronic adaptive change of erythrocytosis and increased oxygen-carrying capacity, thereby allowing ischemia to be avoided during hypoxia. 5,12,16 At the end of 60 minutes, piglets were placed on cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) at an inspired oxygen fraction of 100% for 5 minutes to produce a reoxygenation injury. The aorta was then clamped for 20 minutes at 37°C to add a normothermic ischemic injury to the hypoxic stress.
Hypoxic-ischemic (stress) controls
Ten piglets served as controls for the hypoxic-ischemic stress. Five underwent myocardial biopsy to determine the biochemical changes; the other 5 had the aortic clamp removed and CPB continued for 60 minutes without further ischemia to determine the functional changes. The remaining 25 piglets underwent cardioplegic arrest according to the protocol described in the next section.
Cardioplegic administration
Cardioplegic solutions (CAPS Service; Research Medical Inc, Salt Lake City, Utah) are shown in Tables 1, 2, and 3. Cardioplegic solution was delivered according to a protocol consisting of 5 minutes of warm (37°C) induction(Table 1) followed by 4 minutes of cold multidose cardioplegia(Table 2), a 2-minute cold multidose infusion every 20 minutes, and a 4-minute warm (37°C) cardioplegic reperfusate ("hot shot") before aortic unclamping. In groups 1 through 4 all cardioplegic infusions were delivered antegradely, whereas in group 5 the cardioplegic solution was delivered by a combination of antegrade and retrograde routes. Antegrade infusions were always delivered at a continuously measured aortic root pressure of 40 to 50 mm Hg, and retrograde infusions were delivered at a continuously measured coronary sinus pressure of 30 to 50 mm Hg. Immediately after the start of cardioplegia, piglets were cooled to a systemic temperature of 26°C, and warming to 37°C was begun 16 minutes before aortic unclamping. All piglets undergoing cardioplegic arrest were weaned from CPB with no inotropic support 30 minutes after aortic unclamping. After arterial blood gases, calcium ion, and potassium ion were normalized, final functional and biochemical measurements were made 30 minutes later.
|
|
|
Warm induction alone (group 1, cardioplegic controls)
Five piglets received warm blood cardioplegic induction and then had the aortic crossclamp removed immediately to determine the effect of warm induction without any further ischemia. These piglets therefore acted as a cardioplegic control group, because all subsequent cardioplegia groups (groups 2-5) also received a warm induction.
Intermittent cardioplegia (group 2)
To test the intermittent cardioplegic protection strategy, 5 piglets underwent 70 minutes of ischemic arrest with warm induction followed by cold intermittent cardioplegia every 20 minutes and a warm reperfusate according to the protocol detailed previously.
Integrated strategy (groups 3 through 5)
During the 20-minute intervals between cardioplegic doses, the surgeon does not always require a dry field for optimal visualization. At these times the heart can be perfused to reduce ischemia. To test this strategy (integrated approach), 15 piglets received a maintenance infusion of either unmodified blood (standard integrated strategy, group 3) or a modified nonpotassium blood solution (modified integrated strategy, groups 4 and 5), for the 10 minutes (half the time) immediately before each intermittent cardioplegic infusion. These piglets therefore underwent 10 minutes of ischemia followed by a 10-minute maintenance infusion and then the cardioplegia dose.
Standard integrated strategy (group 3)
To test the standard integrated myocardial protection strategy, 5 piglets received maintenance infusions (between cardioplegic doses) with unmodified blood from the bypass circuit by removing the cardioplegic line from the pump head.
Modified integrated strategy (groups 4 and 5)
Unmodified blood can potentially cause a reperfusion injury because the heart is ischemic between cardioplegic doses and as Rebeyka showed unmodified blood can be detrimental in infants. 1,2,13,14 A modified cardioplegia-like solution might help limit this injury. To test this new approach, the integrated strategy was modified in 10 piglets by infusing a cold modified nonpotassium blood maintenance solution(Table 3
) in place of unmodified blood. The method of delivery was also evaluated, because it is not always possible to deliver antegrade cardioplegia (such as in the arterial switch operation).
Antegrade delivery (group 4)
In 5 piglets the modified maintenance solution as well as all cardioplegic infusions were delivered antegradely.
Retrograde delivery (group 5)
In 5 piglets retrograde delivery was used for the cold modified maintenance infusions as well as the intermittent cold cardioplegic doses. Warm induction and the terminal cardioplegic reperfusate were given antegradely. This examined the effectiveness of the modified integrated strategy for patients in whom antegrade infusions cannot be delivered for part of the procedure (such as those undergoing arterial switch or aortic valve repair).
Myocardial performance
Left ventricular pressure and conductance catheter signals were amplified and digitized to inscribe left ventricular pressure- volume loops after first correcting for parallel conductance (myocardial tissue and blood viscosity) with hypertonic saline solution as previously described. 5,16 Measurements were made before hypoxia (baseline) and 30 minutes after CPB was discontinued. The end-systolic and end-diastolic pressure-volume relationship and preload recruitable stroke were analyzed with the use of a computer graphics program (Spectrum; Bowman-Gray School of Medicine, Winston-Salem, NC), as previously described. 5,12,16 Functional measurements are expressed as percentage recovery of baseline values, with each piglet acting as its own control. After final hemodynamic measurements, all piglets were placed back on bypass, and transmural left ventricular biopsy specimens were obtained for biochemical analysis, with a separate sample obtained for myocardial water determination as previously described.
Physiologic measurements
Coronary vascular resistance (CVR) was determined during each antegrade cardioplegic infusion by measuring coronary sinus pressure and cardioplegic flow once a constant infusion rate with an aortic root pressure between 40 and 50 mm Hg was achieved. CVR was calculated as previously described as the change in pressure across the coronary vascular bed divided by the cardioplegia flow rate, multiplied by 80, and expressed as dynes · s · cm–5. 5,16
Myocardial oxygen consumption
Blood was obtained at 1-minute intervals from the cardioplegia line and coronary sinus across the 4 minutes of warm reperfusion (hot shot, groups 2-5), and myocardial oxygen consumption was determined as previously described elsewhere. 17 The cumulative myocardial oxygen consumption was determined by the sum of the individual 1-minute values and expressed per 100 g of heart tissue, which was determined by weighing the left ventricle at the conclusion of the experiment.
Biochemical analysis
Adenosine pool
Myocardial samples were crushed in a liquid nitrogen–cooled mortar and pestle and lyophilized (Savant Speed Vac Systems, Farmingdale, NY). The adenosine pool was determined as described previously, and ATP levels were expressed as micrograms per gram dry tissue. 5,16
Myeloperoxidase activity
Quantitative myeloperoxidase activity was determined as described previously and is expressed as the change in optical density units per minute per milligram of tissue protein (
OD · min–1 · mg–1 protein). 17
Antioxidant reserve capacity
Myocardial antioxidant reserve capacity (AORC) was assessed as previously described by determining the in vitro lipid peroxidation in cardiac tissue that was homogenized and incubated with t-butylhydroperoxide at a concentration of 4 mmol/L. 12 AORC was expressed as malondialdehyde production in nanomoles per gram of heart tissue protein. The higher the production of malondialdehyde to the oxidant stress (t-butylhydroperoxide), the lower the tissue AORC, indicating depletion of antioxidants secondary to exposure of the heart to oxygen-derived free radicals during reperfusion.
Conjugated diene production
Blood was obtained from the cardioplegia line and coronary sinus 1 and 4 minutes after starting warm reperfusion (hot shot) in groups 2 through 5, and conjugated dienes were assessed as previously described elsewhere. 17 Conjugated diene production was expressed per 100 g of heart tissue by weighing the left ventricle at the conclusion of the experiment.
Myocardial water
Ventricular samples were placed in preweighed vials and dried to a constant weight at a temperature of 85°C. The percentage of myocardial water was calculated according to the following formula: percentage of myocardial water = [(wet weight – dry weight)/wet weight] x 100%.
Clinical studies
The charts of all neonates undergoing an arterial switch operation within the first month of life and of infants undergoing a modified lateral-tunnel Fontan procedure at the University of Illinois or The Heart Institute for Children from July 1, 1996, to December 31, 1998, were retrospectively reviewed. The starting date was chosen because this is when we began to use a modified integrated strategy when applicable in adult and pediatric patients. The clinical cardioplegia protocol consisted of cold induction, followed by cold multidose infusions every 10 to 15 minutes, and finally a substrate-enriched terminal warm reperfusate before removal of the aortic crossclamp. A cold modified (nonpotassium) blood maintenance solution was infused continuously whenever it did not impair optimal visualization. In Fontan procedures, all infusions were given in an antegrade fashion. In arterial switch operations, the cardioplegic induction was delivered antegradely. Thereafter, all cold intermittent cardioplegia and maintenance (modified solution) infusions were delivered retrogradely, because antegrade delivery is impossible with the aorta divided. However, all patients undergoing arterial switch received an antegrade (terminal) warm blood cardioplegic reperfusate before removal of the aortic crossclamp.
Statistics
Data were analyzed with JMP V2.0 (SAS Institute, Inc, Cary, NC) on a Macintosh IIVX computer (Apple Computer, Inc, Cupertino, Calif). Paired Student t tests with 1-way analysis of variance were used for comparison of variables among experimental groups. If the analysis of variance revealed a significant interaction, pairwise tests of individual group means were compared by means of multiple comparisons (Tukey test) at significance levels of P < .05, P < .01, and P < .001. Group data are expressed as mean ± SEM.
Results
There was no statistically significant difference (P > .2) between groups for baseline (prehypoxic) values (slopes) of left ventricular contractility (end-systolic elastance 35 ± 2 mm Hg/mL), diastolic compliance (0.04 ± 0.01), or preload recruitable stroke work (68 ± 3 æ[mm Hg · mL]/mL).
Hemodynamic and physiologic measurements
Results are depicted in Figures 1 through 4. There were no significant changes or differences (P > .2) in the x-axis intercept (V0) for end-systolic elastance or preload recruitable stoke work between prebypass (baseline) and postbypass values in any cardioplegic group. Therefore, the change in slope of end-systolic elastance and preload recruitable stroke work could be interpreted to represent variability in the contractile state of the myocardium relative to baseline values. This also allowed the change in slope to be expressed as a percentage of baseline, with each piglet acting as its own control. The combination of hypoxia and ischemia caused such a severe injury that bypass could not be discontinued in piglets not receiving cardioplegia (hypoxic-ischemic controls), despite an additional 60 minutes of CPB support. Thus no postbypass functional measurements could be obtained in these piglets. In contrast, warm induction without ischemia (group 1, cardioplegic controls) partially resuscitated the hypoxic-ischemic myocardium, thereby allowing bypass to be discontinued. However, these piglets still had depressed postbypass systolic contractility (end-systolic elastance 39% ± 3%), markedly increased diastolic stiffness (271% ± 8%), and reduced preload recruitable stroke work (40% ± 2%). Adding 70 minutes of cardioplegic ischemia with multidose cold intermittent cardioplegic infusions (group 2) preserved but did not improve myocardial function, as it was identical (P > .2) to hearts receiving warm cardioplegia without further ischemia (group 1). In contrast, postbypass function was slightly improved if a maintenance solution of cold unmodified blood (standard integrated protection) was given for 10 minutes between intermittent cardioplegic infusions (group 3). However, there was complete functional recovery if the maintenance infusions used a modified nonpotassium blood solution (modified integrated strategy). These improved results were independent of whether the modified solution was infused antegradely (group 4) or retrogradely (group 5). CVR followed a similar trend. The CVR decreased to normal when the heart was protected with a modified integrated strategy, delivered either antegradely or retrogradely (groups 4 and 5). 5,16 Piglets that received retrograde delivery (group 5), however, only had CVR determined during warm induction and reperfusion, because CVR measurements were made during antegrade infusions. In contrast, the CVR remained elevated in groups 2 (intermittent) and 3 (standard integrated strategy), although there was a slight improvement (decrease) in piglets receiving maintenance infusions of unmodified blood (standard integrated strategy).
|
|
|
|
|
|
With an in vivo, clinically applicable animal model, this study demonstrates (1) that the conventional techniques of intermittent multidose blood cardioplegia alone or with maintenance infusions of cold unmodified blood (standard integrated strategy) provides inadequate protection of the stressed (hypoxic-ischemic) neonatal heart, (2) that infusion of a cold modified nonpotassium maintenance blood solution between intermittent cardioplegia doses (modified integrated strategy) completely resuscitates the stressed neonatal heart, restoring myocardial, metabolic, and vascular function, (3) that the modified solution is equally effective delivered in an antegrade or retrograde fashion, and (4) that this method has been applied successfully to 72 hypoxic (stressed) pediatric patients, with excellent results.
Chronically hypoxic (cyanotic) patients have reduced ATP levels secondary to ischemic insults during times of increased stress (eg, tachycardia, exercise). 2,6-8,10,11 To simulate the cyanotic child undergoing operative repair, piglets therefore underwent both hypoxic and ischemic stress. Although an acute stress does not exactly mimic chronic hypoxia, several studies have demonstrated similar changes with reoxygenation of acutely hypoxic piglets and chronically hypoxic infants. 12,18-23 In addition, despite the absence of adaptation, we characterized almost identical changes in 21 cyanotic infants with the same biochemical tests as those used in our acute experimental studies. 20 It is important to use stressed (hypoxic-ischemic) hearts when investigating cardioplegic strategies, because they are more sensitive to changes in protection. 1,5,8,9,16,17,20 Consequently, our model provides information about the patients most vulnerable to postoperative dysfunction. This approach parallels the evolution of cardioplegia strategies in adults, where acute ischemia has been used to mimic the chronic clinical conditions of angina and cardiogenic shock. 1
The hypoxic-ischemic stress produced a significant oxygen-derived free radical–mediated injury, resulting in cellular damage that was so severe that CPB could not be discontinued. However, warm induction was able to partially resuscitate the hypoxic-ischemic neonatal heart, and despite the addition of 70 minutes of ischemic arrest, intermittent infusions of cold blood cardioplegia preserved hemodynamic and metabolic function at levels identical to warm induction without further ischemia. Intermittent cardioplegia therefore effectively prevents any further myocardial damage, but is unable to improve the stress injury. Conversely, infusion of a maintenance solution of unmodified blood between intermittent cardioplegic infusions (standard integrated strategy) improved functional and metabolic recovery. However, this effect was maximized only if a modified (nonpotassium) blood solution was used for the maintenance infusions. This improvement was independent of the method of delivery, with antegrade and retrograde infusions resulting in similar recoveries. This implies that maintenance infusions of a cold modified solution do more than just limit ischemia during cardioplegic arrest, they also actively resuscitate the stressed heart, because a modified solution improved functional and metabolic recovery relative to piglets receiving warm induction without ischemia. This conclusion is further supported by the finding that a modified maintenance solution (modified integrated strategy) improved recovery to a greater extent than continuous infusions of unmodified blood (standard integrated strategy), despite the fact that both these approaches reduce ischemia equally by providing oxygenated blood during myocardial arrest.
Previously only warm blood cardioplegia has been demonstrated to have the ability to resuscitate the stressed heart. 1,4 Normothermia is thought to be necessary to optimize the enzymatic reactions needed for cellular repair. Why such a dramatic improvement occurs when a modified maintenance solution is infused at 4°C is unknown, but it suggests that the solution is working through a mechanism that is not dependent on enzymatic activity. It is possible that the same effect would have occurred if the modified solution had been infused under normothermic conditions. Keeping the heart warm is potentially dangerous, however, because it is less tolerant to ischemic intervals when the infusion are interrupted or if cardioplegic distribution is not adequate to all myocardial segments. Maintenance infusions were given for only half the time between cardioplegic infusions, to mimic the clinical situation in which infusions must occasionally be interrupted to optimize visualization needed for surgical repair. The maintenance infusions were always delivered at a measured pressure of 30 to 50 mm Hg, because infusion of intermittent cardioplegia at higher pressures (>80 mm Hg) is detrimental to stressed neonatal hearts. 24 These lower pressures (30-50 mm Hg) are probably even more important with continuous delivery, because the heart is exposed to this pressure for a prolonged period. The modified solution used for the maintenance infusions was based on our multidose cardioplegia solution, but the potassium was removed to avoid postbypass hyperkalemia. 1 Furthermore, potassium is probably not required, because the cold arrested heart tends to stay that way if it is maintained at 4°C. 1,4 To ensure myocardial quiescence, however, potassium cardioplegia is still given every 20 minutes, or whenever the continuous infusions are interrupted, because the arrested heart can have small-amplitude ventricular fibrillation develop; this is not always visible but still results in increased oxygen consumption and ischemia. 1,25 Whether any particular component in the modified solution is more important is unknown. Because each component was found to be important in multidose cardioplegic solutions, however, the same is probably true of the modified solution.
CVR was measured with each cardioplegic infusion to determine the effects of each strategy on vascular function. Vascular dysfunction can adversely affect myocardial protection by altering cardioplegic distribution. The coronary vasculature normally vasodilates after ischemia, resulting in a decrease in CVR. The CVR should therefore be reduced after the 20-minute ischemic stress, as well as between intermittent cardioplegic doses. However, the CVR was increased with warm induction and remained elevated with each intermittent cardioplegic infusion. This implies vascular dysfunction as a result of a vascular injury, as well as that this injury persists throughout the period of cardioplegic arrest. In contrast, the CVR progressively decreased with each cardioplegic infusion in hearts receiving integrated protection. This improvement was greatest in the group receiving maintenance infusions of a nonpotassium modified blood solution (modified integrated strategy). These infusions, however, should have had the opposite effect, because they reduce ischemia between cardioplegic doses so that the coronary vasculature should not need to vasodilate. This decrease in CVR therefore implies progressive repair of a vascular injury with normalization of vascular function. We cannot be certain that the normalization of CVR indicates repair of the vascular injury, because specific test of vascular function were not done after bypass. That is the most likely explanation, however, because CVR directly correlates with functional and metabolic recovery.
On the basis of these experimental results, we began using a modified integrated strategy whenever possible in both adult and pediatric patients, because this concept should be independent of age. We chose patients undergoing a Fontan or arterial switch procedure for this retrospective review only because these patients all received this method of protection. These two groups also allowed us to evaluate different methods of delivery and age groups, because the patients undergoing Fontan procedures were older and received antegrade delivery, whereas those undergoing arterial switch operations were neonates and received retrograde delivery. As in the experimental studies, the maintenance infusions were occasionally interrupted. However, they were only stopped when visualization was problematic, such as when working around the coronary sinus in Fontan procedures or the left main coronary artery in arterial switch operations. Despite the high-risk nature of these two groups, the results were excellent and support the clinical application and safety of this approach.
Relative to antegrade delivery, retrograde delivery provides superior perfusion of the vulnerable left ventricular subendocardium and septum, especially in the setting of coronary occlusion or ventricular hypertrophy. 1,26-28 This study suggests that another reason to use retrograde cardioplegia is to provide cardioplegic delivery whenever frequent antegrade infusions are not possible (such as with arterial switch procedures). In contrast to adults, however, protection of the right ventricle is often more important in pediatric patients because of the frequent problems of right ventricular hypertrophy and postoperative pulmonary hypertension. 2,6 The pediatric surgeon must therefore be careful about relying solely on retrograde delivery, because it may not supply adequate nutritive flow to the right ventricular free wall, especially at normothermia. 26-28 This was the reason that the terminal warm reperfusate (hot shot) was always delivered antegrade, because this helps to compensate for any inadequacies in right ventricular free wall protection by repairing cellular damage that may have occurred during cold cardioplegic arrest.
In summary, this study demonstrated the advantages of infusing a modified (nonpotassium) blood maintenance solution whenever possible, not only to limit ischemia but to help resuscitate the damaged (stressed) heart, thus improving postoperative myocardial, metabolic, and vascular function. These infusions are equally effective whether delivered in an antegrade or retrograde fashion and have been used successfully for high-risk patients. Because the stressed (hypoxic) heart is more sensitive to ischemia as well as more predisposed toward post myocardial dysfunction, surgeons should consider incorporating a modified integrated strategy into their clinical practice. 2,6-9
Appendix: Discussion
Dr David Clarke (Denver, Colo). Congratulations to Allen and colleagues for a meticulous and obviously carefully constructed experimental study and some obviously superb clinical results.
I would like to address three areas. The first involves the induction of the ischemic stress before the cardioplegic protection. You seem to have gone to a great deal of effort to simulate the clinical situation by limiting your continuous infusion to only half the period to allow time for possibly complex portions of the repair. Yet at the beginning of your protocol you subjected the hearts to 20 minutes of unprotected warm ischemia, which is something that I at least try to avoid in the clinical situation. Perhaps you could comment on the rationale for this approach.
Dr Allen. The hypoxic ischemic stress was our way of simulating a cyanotic (hypoxic) infant undergoing operative repair. We first subjected the piglets to 1 hour of hypoxia. However, our model of acute hypoxia does not result in any ischemia or ATP depletion, whereas most cyanotic children have reduced ATP levels at the time of surgery as a result of ischemic insults during times of increased stress (eg, tachycardia and exercise). We therefore added a 20-minute ischemic insult to more closely simulate the chronically hypoxic (cyanotic) patient. We recognize that this acute stress (hypoxia-ischemia) does not exactly mimic the chronically hypoxic (cyanotic) child. However, several studies have demonstrated similar changes after reoxygenation of the chronically hypoxic infant, and we recently documented an identical injury in 21 cyanotic infants with the same biochemical tests as those used in our acute experimental studies. It is important to test cardioplegic protocols in stressed (hypoxic) hearts, because they are more sensitive to changes in myocardial protection and are the most vulnerable to postoperative dysfunction. This is why adult studies usually subject the heart to an acute ischemic stress by crossclamping the aorta, even though this does not exactly mimic the clinical conditions of chronic ischemia or heart failure.
Dr Clarke. The next issue involves the flows and volumes that were used in the administration of the various solutions. In your article you indicated that you tried to maintain certain pressures in the aortic root and certain pressures in the coronary sinus, and you also indicated the durations of these infusions of the warm cardioplegia, the cold cardioplegia, and your modified solution. I could probably do the math, because you did mention CVR, but I would really appreciate it if you would tell me how much volume this requires and give your flow rates. I have tried in the operating room to give antegrade cardioplegia continuously on numerous occasions at low flow rates and found that it is almost impossible to keep the aortic valve closed, and the cardioplegic solution therefore runs off in the ventricular vent. With higher flows, it would seem to me that you would have a great deal of difficulty doing some of your more complex transatrial repairs, such as atrioventricular septal defect or transatrial tetralogy repairs. Would you like to comment on this?
Dr Allen. We usually do not measure cardioplegia volumes but deliver cardioplegic solution at a given pressure (30-50 mm Hg) across a specific time interval, because oxygen and nutrients are taken up with time, not by a specific dose. In these studies this usually resulted in a flow rate into the aorta or coronary sinus of around 50 mL/min. I believe that it is important to always measure the cardioplegic infusion pressure, because high pressures can be detrimental, especially to hypoxic tissue, whereas low pressures signify inadequate delivery. A low infusion pressure is often due to a technical problem. If the cardioplegic delivery pressure remains low despite adequate flows, the surgeon should first try to correct the underlying cause. Simply giving a set volume that is inadequately delivered yields a false sense of security that the cardioplegic solution is protecting the heart. In cases of severe aortic insufficiency, I would not persist in trying to keep the aortic valve closed and the pressure adequate. In these cases I would either open the aorta and give cardioplegic soltuion directly into the coronary arteries or switch to retrograde delivery. Finally, continuous infusions should only be given when they do not impair visualization. During these times, we rely on intermittent cardioplegia alone.
Dr Clarke. My last question is somewhat related. At the flows that I believe are required to maintain the pressures that you indicated, you are probably giving a larger amount of solution. I have used continuous retrograde cardioplegia for a number of years at 1 mL · kg–1 · min–1 and have not really had serious problems with hyperkalemia. It seems to me that what you are doing here is a combination of potassium cardioplegia and magnesium cardioplegia. I wonder whether there is a significant advantage to having hypermagnesemia in the early postoperative period as opposed to hyperkalemia. Perhaps you can comment on this. Have you measured magnesium levels in the experimental situation or in the clinical situation?
Dr Allen. Yes, we have used a modified integrated strategy with this type of solution clinically for several years in both adult and pediatric patients. We also currently add magnesium to our intermittent cardioplegic infusions. To the best of my knowledge we have not had a problem with high postoperative magnesium levels, and Hearse* has shown that cardioplegic solutions with magnesium levels as high as 16 mEq/L are safe. We use a magnesium-free bypass prime, and several studies have shown that there is depletion of intracellular magnesium with initiation of CPB, as well as during cardioplegic arrest. In some respects what we are doing by adding magnesium to the cardioplegic and maintenance solutions is restoring the intracellular magnesium that would normally be depleted by CPB. An increased magnesium level should not be problematic, because it prevents arrhythmias, and any adverse myocardial effects can easily be reversed with calcium. For this reason, we believe it is extremely important to normalize ionic calcium levels in the upper range of normal before discontinuing bypass, especially if a patient receives a large amount of cardioplegic solution.
Dr John Hawkins (Salt Lake City, Utah). Were your study animals perfused at normothermia or hypothermia?
Dr Allen. The temperature was reduced to 25°C immediately on initiation of CPB, and the piglets were rewarmed about 16 minutes before removal of the aortic crossclamp. We began rewarming the animals approximately 12 minutes before the terminal warm reperfusate.
Dr Hawkins. So the body temperature was kept cold the whole time.
Dr Allen. Correct.
Dr Hawkins. With intermittent cardioplegia you do get some myocardial warming if the body temperature is warm, and I wonder what role that simple cooling had in this. In other words, the continuous infusion simply kept the heart colder and may not have much to do with the mixture versus intermittent cardioplegia with a body temperature that was somewhat warm.
Dr Allen. No, this does not explain the findings. When we gave a warm induction and then removed the aortic clamp, there was only 40% recovery of overall myocardial function, despite no cardioplegic ischemia. Furthermore, recovery was still not complete when we infused cold unmodified blood between cardioplegic infusions (standard integrated), despite the fact that the heart was kept cold and perfused with an oxygenated solution. In contrast, there was complete recovery if a cold modified solution was used for the maintenance infusions. Thus, neither temperature nor oxygen alone explains our results. Instead, by some unknown mechanism a cold modified solution allows the heart to repair the hypoxic-ischemic stress.
Acknowledgments
We acknowledge Dr Gerald D. Buckberg for his collaboration and consultation, Ms Katherine Tubeszewski, RN, MSN, for her help with clinical data collection, and the organizational and secretarial assistance of Ms Tina Green.
Footnotes
Read at the Twenty-sixth Annual Meeting of The Western Thoracic Surgical Association, The Big Island of Hawaii, June 21-25, 2000. 
* Hearse DJ, Stewart DA, Braimbridge MV. Myocardial protection during ischemic cardiac arrest: the importance of magnesium in cardioplegic infusates. J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg. 1978;75:877-85.
References
This article has been cited by other articles:
|
|
 |
|
  M. J. Barth, B. S. Allen, M. Gulecyuz, P. Chiemmongkoltip, B. Cuneo, and M. N. Ilbawi Experience with an alternative technique for the management of anomalous left coronary artery from the pulmonary artery Ann. Thorac. Surg., November 1, 2003; 76(5): 1429 - 1434. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
|
|
|
|
|
|
B. S. Allen, C. El-Zein, B. Cuneo, J. P. Cava, M. J. Barth, and M. N. Ilbawi Pericardial tissue valves and gore-tex conduits as an alternative for right ventricular outflow tract replacement in children Ann. Thorac. Surg., September 1, 2002; 74(3): 771 - 777. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF]
|
|
|
|
 |
|
 B. S Allen The role of leukodepletion in limiting ischemia/reperfusion damage in the heart, lung and lower extremity Perfusion, March 1, 2002; 17(2_suppl): 11 - 22. [Abstract] [PDF]
|
|
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |
