|
|
||||||||
J Thorac Cardiovasc Surg 2008;136:383-391
© 2008 The American Association for Thoracic Surgery
General Thoracic Surgery |
a Thoracic Surgery Division, Carlo Poma Hospital, Mantova, Italy
b Anesthesiology Unit, Carlo Poma Hospital, Mantova, Italy
c Pneumology Division, Carlo Poma Hospital, Mantova, Italy
Received for publication March 10, 2008; revisions received April 22, 2008; accepted for publication April 25, 2008. * Address for reprints: Andrea Droghetti, MD, Viale Albertoni 1, Thoracic Surgery Division, Carlo Poma Hospital, 46100 Mantova, Italy. (Email: ADroghetti{at}libero.it).
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Methods: There were 20 patients in each of the 2 groups: Electrocautery was used for precision dissection and collagen patches were coated with human fibrinogen and thrombin (TachoSil, Nycomed, Vienna, Austria) for aerostasis in the electrocautery and sealant group (ES), and the approved routine surgical procedure with staplers was used in the stapler group (ST).
Results: Statistically significant reductions of air leakage were found in the ES group in the overall incidence of air leaks (50% vs 95%, P = .0001), duration of air leaks (1.7 days vs 4.5 days, P = .003), and procedure costs (425 euros vs 630.5 euros, P = .0001). There were no complications related to the use of the patches, and a significantly lower incidence of dead pleural space was observed in the ES group (5% vs 40%, P = .020).
Conclusion: The use of electrocautery dissection and collagen patches coated with human fibrinogen and thrombin (TachoSil, Nycomed, Vienna, Austria) for aerostasis to complete interlobar fissures seems to be safe and effective in reducing alveolar air leaks and procedure costs. Although this pilot study showed advantages in terms of hospitalization and cost benefits, further multicentric studies are required to clarify that these differences are statistically significant.
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
|
Pulmonary lobectomy, performed by the division of the parenchyma through scission of the fissures, remains the standard therapeutic option in most patients with early-stage non–small cell lung cancer. Persistent alveolar air leaks, the most common complication after major pulmonary resection with an incidence of 3% to 25%, occur more frequently when interlobar fissures are incomplete. Persistent alveolar air leaks have negative consequences on morbidity (empyema, deep vein thrombosis, and respiratory infections), culminating in increased hospitalization with negative economic effects and delays of adjuvant treatment.1-10
Most air leaks result from dissection of the fissures as demonstrated by the intraoperative air leaks exhibited by the traumatized lung tissue. Surgical staplers are widely used to complete fissures, usually providing reliable hemostasis but without obtaining an airtight closure for parenchymal tears at lung reexpansion under ventilation.1,2
We designed a randomized prospective controlled study to compare 2 different techniques to complete interlobar fissures during pulmonary lobectomy. Forty patients were enrolled and randomly assigned to 1 of the 2 procedures. In the electrocautery and sealant group (ES), electrocautery was used for precision dissection (a technique that was initially developed by Perelman11
), and a collagen patch coated with human fibrinogen and thrombin (TachoSil) was applied for aerostasis. In the stapler group (ST) approved routine surgical procedure with staplers was performed.
The trial was conducted according to the ethical principles of the Declaration of Helsinki and in accordance with local requirements and good clinical practice. This document was written according to the International Conference on Harmonisation E9 (Statistical Principles for Clinical Trials) and E3 (Structure and Content of Clinical Study Reports) guidelines of the European Agency for the Evaluation of Medicinal Products.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The first goal was to assess the percentage of demonstrated intraoperative alveolar air leak effectively sealed after application of the patch (TachoSil) in ES and to compare the proportion of patients in the experimental and control groups who were free of air leaks throughout hospitalization.
The second goal was to compare the experimental group with a control group in terms of the postoperative day that the last air leak was observed, the moment of chest tube removal, and the length of hospitalization. Other aspects that were analyzed were the costs of the procedure and hospitalization, and the safety of the experimental procedure in comparison with standard procedure by surveillance of the incidence and severity of complications.
Patient Selection
The study was performed at Carlo Poma Hospital, Mantova, Italy, during a period of 11 months (May of 2006 to April of 2007). Patients with early-stage non–small cell lung cancer who were scheduled for elective pulmonary lobectomy were eligible for inclusion in the study. The purpose of the study and potential risks and benefits of the procedure were explained to all patients, who were required to give signed informed consent before entering the trial.
During surgery, patients were deemed ineligible for further participation if the surgical treatment was completed by a video-assisted approach; if they underwent pneumonectomy, sleeve resection, or bronchoplasty; if they had an inoperable disease; or if other sealant materials were used.
At thoracotomy, fissures were defined according to Craig's classification: grade 1, complete fissure with entirely separate lobes; grade 2, complete visceral cleft but parenchymal fusion at the base of the fissure; grade 3, visceral cleft evident for part of the fissure; grade 4, complete fusion of the lobes with no evident fissural line.12
Only patients with fissures in grades 3 and 4 were included in the study.
Randomization
Forty patients were randomized into 2 groups of 20. Randomization was performed intraoperatively using closed envelopes containing notes reading either "ES" for electrocautery and sealant or "ST" for conventional treatment with staplers. The groups were matched for sex, age, risk factors, duration of surgery, length of fissures, and type of lobectomy (
Table 1).
|
Electrocautery and Sealant Group
Precision dissection of fissures, consisting of a gradual and accurate separation of lung tissue through punctate electrocoagulation and isolated application of ligatures, was conducted with the use of magnifying lenses. During the procedure, the assistant retracted the tissue of the lobe being removed as the surgeon held back the lung tissue of the other lobe with the forceps. In the other hand the surgeon held a forceps for electrocoagulation with which he/she gripped 1 small portion of tissue at a time and then coagulated it. Visible branches of the bronchial tree and larger vascular branches were ligated rather than coagulated. After completion of fissures by electrocautery, parenchymal leakage was evaluated by submersion of the resection site in saline and reventilation of the lung, applying a peak pressure of 25 to 35 cm H2O. Leakage was graded according to Macchiarini's scale as 0 (no leakage), 1 (single bubbles), 2 (stream of bubbles), or 3 (coalescent bubbles).13
No other procedures were performed for all grades of leakage. The only aerostatic procedure performed in this group was the application of a sterile, ready to use, completely absorbable 9.5 x 4.8 x 0.5-cm3 collagen patch coated with human fibrinogen and thrombin (TachoSil). After premoistening with physiologic saline, with the lung moderately ventilated, the patch was easily applied by pressing it to the pulmonary surface at least 1 cm beyond the margin of dissection (
Figures 1 and 2).
|
|
After Surgery
Afterward, all patients received single drainage (28F or 32F) and were connected to a Pleur-evac system (Pleur-evac A-7000-08LF, Genzyme Surgical Products Corporation, Fall River, Massachussets, USA) with a 7-column air leak meter. All patients initially had their chest tube placed on –20 cm H2O suction in the operating room, in an attempt to establish initial reexpansion of the lung, and underwent chest radiography after extubation. Patients were disconnected from suction for transfer to the recovery unit. On arrival in the recovery room, patients were placed back on –20 cm H2O suction. On the basis of results from previous randomized trials, chest tubes were always placed to water seal 48 hours after surgery.3,14,15
Air leaks were catalogued twice daily according to the classification reported by Cerfolio and colleagues3
as expiratory, forced expiratory, inspiratory, or continuous and were scored from 1 to 7 by the Pleur-evac air leak meter (
Figure 3). To remove the tube, the volume of drained fluids was required to be less than 100 mL during the preceding 24-hour period and all air leaks resolved.
|
The estimated daily cost of hospitalization per patient was 800 euros. For each patient assigned to the ST group, 1 device complete with recharge was used, and additional recharges were supplied when necessary. The cost of each stapler was 355 euros for the device with the first recharge and 190 euros for each additional recharge. In the ES procedure, the cost of each patch was 315 euros.
Follow-up
One and 3 months after surgery, the treated patients underwent a clinical examination and chest radiography. A chest computed tomography was performed after 6 months.
Statistical Methods
All of the statistical procedures described were performed with the SAS package (SAS, Version 9.1.2; SAS Institute Inc, Cary, NC). The significance level was set to 5% (
= 0.05) for all efficacy and safety parameters. The 2 procedures were compared by the unpaired t test or Wilcoxon's 2-sample test applied to discrete or continuous data, and by the chi-square test or Fisher exact test when appropriate, applied to dichotomous or categoric data. Stratified analysis of categoric data was performed with the Cochran-Mantel-Haenszel procedure. The normality of data distribution was assessed by the Shapiro-Wilk test.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The average length of fissures in the ES group was 128.3 mm (range 95–190 mm), and the average length of stapled parenchyma in the ST was 96.3 mm (range 80–195 mm), with no statistically significant difference (P [Wilcoxon's 2-sample test] = .084). There was no significant difference in the length of time required to perform the 2 techniques (Table 1).
Air Leaks
There was a 100% incidence of intraoperative air leaks in the ES group after electrocautery dissection and before application of TachoSil, which was higher than the incidence of 90% among patients of the ST group. The distribution of air leaks in the ES group, according to Macchiarini's scale, was as follows: 4 patients (20%) with grade 1 air leaks, 9 patients (45%) with grade 2 air leaks, and 7 patients (35%) with grade 3 air leaks. In the ST group there were 4 patients (20%) with grade 1 leaks and 14 patients (70%) with grade 2 air leaks, whereas there were no grade 3 air leaks.
Because the difference in distribution of the scores of Macchiarini's scale was significant (P = .028), 2 further tests were performed by grouping the severity scores as follows: first test, scores 0 to 1 versus scores 2 to 3; second test, scores 0 to 2 versus score 3. The results of the second test show that the incidence of score 3 was significantly higher in the ES group (P = .008) (
Table 2). The significant difference in air leakage volume observed intraoperatively (ES > ST) was inverted after application of the patch and maintained for the entire postsurgical period (
Figure 4). Postsurgery, the incidence in the ES group was 40% (8/20 patients), which was significantly lower than the 80% incidence of the ST group (16/20 patients) (P = .010); this significant difference was confirmed during the period from day 0 to the end of hospitalization (ST 95% vs ES 50%, P = .001).
|
|
|
|
Leak of Liquid
For each patient, the cumulative and average leak of liquid during the observation period and the days with leaks were calculated. The results do not show any statistically significant difference between procedures. In the ES group, the daily drainage leak was 270 mL versus 234.7 mL in the ST group (P =.053). The mean duration of liquid leaks (>100 mL/24 h) for the trial population was 7.1 in the ES group, which was shorter than the 8.4 days in the ST group (P [Wilcoxon's 2-sample test] = .837) (
Figure 7).
|
|
|
Hospitalization
The difference in mean hospitalization length of the 2 procedures did not achieve statistical significance; however, in the ES group it was 11.0 days (range 9–17 days), which was shorter than the 14.3 days (range 8–57 days) in the ST group (
Figure 10).
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Many procedures, such as the application of fibrin glue,17-19
synthetic sealant,20,21
and biodegradable sealant22,23
reinforcement of pulmonary closure with various materials,24,25
and the use of laser,26,27
ultrasonic dissection,28
and autologous blood patch10
have been proposed to control and prevent air leaks (
Table 3).
|
We agree with Stolz and colleagues16
that staplers have a greater capacity in preventing air leaks than manual dissection alone. We observed a significantly greater incidence and severity of intraoperative air leaks in the ES group, but we demonstrated a relevant reduction of these on postoperative day 1 after application of TachoSil. This reduction of approximately 60% was maintained throughout hospitalization with an inversion of incidence between the 2 groups. The ES group showed a trend toward a reduction in the proportion of patients with leakage after more than 48 hours and more than 7 days, as well as a reduction in the mean leakage volumes at these times. The mean duration of the occuence of air leaks was significantly shorter in the ES group (1.7 vs 4.5 days, P = .003), and the ratio between the time to the last occurrence of air leak and the length of scissure was also significantly smaller in the ES group (0.015 vs 0.059 days/mm, P < .001).
The multiple aspects of the better sealant results in the ES group and the ability of the regulated dissection to preserve as much pulmonary parenchyma as possible permit the residual lung to be bigger and maintain more elasticity than after being stapled with a better capacity to fill the thoracic cavity. This led to a minor incidence of complications such as dead pleural space in the ES group.
The benefits of TachoSil translated to a reduction of more than 48 hours in the mean time of chest drain removal and more than 3 days in hospitalization, although this trend did not reach statistical significance in our study because of the small size of the population from whom the results were drawn.
Inasmuch as patients must remain under clinical observation during chest drainage and tube removal is conditioned not only by the presence of air leaks but also by the liquid leaks, the period of hospitalization was not significantly reduced in the experimental group because the duration of liquid leaks was similar in the 2 groups. Although the incidence of dead pleural space was significantly lower in the ES group, the incidence of overall complications was also lower in the ES group, but the difference was not statistically significant.
| Conclusions |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Acknowledgments |
|---|
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
A. Hashimoto, M. Kuwabara, Y. Hirasaki, H. Tsujimoto, T. Torii, T. Nakamura, and A. Hagiwara Reduction of air leaks in a canine model of pulmonary resection with a new staple-line buttress J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., August 1, 2011; 142(2): 366 - 371. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. De Leyn, M.-R. Muller, J. W. A. Oosterhuis, T. Schmid, C. K. C. Choong, W. Weder, and Y. Sokolow Prospective European multicenter randomized trial of PleuraSeal for control of air leaks after elective pulmonary resection J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., April 1, 2011; 141(4): 881 - 887. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
S. Singhal and J. B. Shrager Should buttresses and sealants be used to manage pulmonary parenchymal air leaks? J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., December 1, 2010; 140(6): 1220 - 1225. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
O. Rena, E. Papalia, T. C. Mineo, F. Massera, E. Pirondini, D. Turello, and C. Casadio Air-leak management after upper lobectomy in patients with fused fissure and chronic obstructive pulmonary disease: a pilot trial comparing sealant and standard treatment Interact CardioVasc Thorac Surg, December 1, 2009; 9(6): 973 - 977. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. Terzi, P. Scanagatta, and G. Rizzardi Stapler versus precision dissection and sealant in comparing completion technique of fissures for lobectomy: True or statistical advantages? J. Thorac. Cardiovasc. Surg., February 1, 2009; 137(2): 507 - 507. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| ANN THORAC SURG | ASIAN CARDIOVASC THORAC ANN | EUR J CARDIOTHORAC SURG |
| J THORAC CARDIOVASC SURG | ICVTS | ALL CTSNet JOURNALS |